Businessman Won't Give Up: A Decade After Crane Bank’s Closure, the Legal Questions Are Far From Settled

 

By Allen Kansiime

Nearly a decade after the Bank of Uganda seized Crane Bank and transferred selected assets and liabilities to dfcu Bank, businessman Sudhir Ruparelia's long-running legal battle over the controversial takeover has entered a critical phase in London, bringing foreign investors linked to dfcu under renewed scrutiny.

The substantive trial in Crane Bank Limited and Others v dfcu Bank Limited and Others opened at the Commercial Court in London on October 5, 2026, with proceedings expected to run for approximately 12 weeks. The claimants, led by Ruparelia, are seeking about £200 million in damages over what they describe as an unlawful takeover that deprived them of their investment at a gross undervalue.

At the centre of the dispute is the January 2017 transaction through which dfcu acquired selected assets and liabilities of Crane Bank following the Bank of Uganda's intervention in the institution.

The claimants argue that the process was fundamentally flawed and that the transaction involved misconduct by dfcu, its shareholders and other individuals and institutions. They are challenging both the circumstances under which the takeover was arranged and the roles played by various parties connected to dfcu's ownership and management.

Among those attracting attention are foreign-linked investment interests, including Rabo Partnerships, a subsidiary of Dutch banking group Rabobank, and Norfinance, alongside individuals associated with dfcu's board and ownership structure.

Crane Bank, founded by Ruparelia in 1995, grew into one of Uganda's largest indigenous commercial banks before the central bank placed it under statutory management on October 20, 2016, citing serious capital and liquidity concerns.

Three months later, in January 2017, the Bank of Uganda transferred selected assets and liabilities of the bank to dfcu under a Purchase of Assets and Assumption of Liabilities agreement. The transaction involved a stated consideration of Shs200 billion payable to the central bank.

However, Crane Bank's former shareholders have consistently disputed the legality and fairness of the process, arguing that the transaction was concluded without a proper independent valuation of the bank's assets and liabilities. They have also questioned the circumstances under which dfcu was approached as a prospective buyer before the relevant processes were sufficiently established.

One of the significant issues raised by the claimants concerns an internal email from late 2016 relating to $27.5 million, equivalent to approximately Shs99 billion, and connected to the disposal of a portfolio of Crane Bank loans.

The claimants contend that the communication indicated that the money would be transferred to the central bank without being properly recorded. They have characterised the proposed arrangement as evidence of bribery and misconduct surrounding the transaction.

The legal arguments have also drawn on the US conviction of Hong Kong intermediary Patrick Ho for bribing officials in Uganda in connection with the business interests of a Chinese conglomerate. The claimants argue that the circumstances surrounding that case provide relevant context to questions about the handling of the Crane Bank transaction.

dfcu has rejected the claims, maintaining that Crane Bank was seriously undercapitalised and that the Bank of Uganda acted lawfully to resolve the financially distressed institution while protecting depositors and the wider financial system.

The bank has also defended the transaction, arguing that it followed due diligence and valuation processes. Regarding the disputed $27.5 million arrangement, dfcu maintains that it was connected to legitimate repayment of emergency financial support rather than bribery.

The valuation and forensic investigations have also featured prominently in the competing accounts presented in the dispute, with court-related material distinguishing between work undertaken by KPMG and reports prepared by PwC.

Norwegian investment interests associated with Norfund have also rejected the allegations, while former Rabobank executives Albert Jonkergouw and Willem Cramer, who served on dfcu's board, are among the individuals drawn into the proceedings.

The London trial follows years of legal and parliamentary scrutiny in Uganda over the circumstances surrounding Crane Bank's closure and subsequent transfer.

In 2019, Parliament's Committee on Commissions, Statutory Authorities and State Enterprises (COSASE), then chaired by Abdu Katuntu, raised concerns about aspects of the Bank of Uganda's handling of the institution's resolution.

The committee questioned the timing of the inventory and audit processes, particularly the fact that dfcu had been invited to bid before the inventory report was completed. It also raised concerns about the absence of a prior valuation of Crane Bank's assets and liabilities before the transfer agreement was concluded.

The dispute has gained fresh significance in Kampala following a separate confrontation between Ruparelia and the Bank of Uganda over Shs219.4 billion in outstanding liquidity support extended to Crane Bank.

On November 10, 2026, Bank of Uganda Governor Michael Atingi-Ego told COSASE that the central bank continued to regard the amount as recoverable from Crane Bank and its former shareholders.

Ruparelia has rejected the demand, arguing that the former shareholders should not be held personally liable for obligations arising after the central bank took control of the institution on October 20, 2016, suspended its board and appointed a statutory manager.

His position is that the shareholders had lost control of the bank following the intervention and could therefore not be held responsible for decisions and financial obligations arising under the statutory manager's administration. He has invoked the principle of limited liability in challenging the central bank's position.

Atingi-Ego, however, cautioned MPs that discussing the disputed liquidity support could affect the ongoing London proceedings because the central bank's intervention and subsequent actions form part of the wider dispute before the foreign court. He urged the committee to defer substantive questioning on sensitive matters or consider handling them in a closed session.

For Ruparelia and the other claimants, the London proceedings provide an opportunity to have their allegations examined through a substantive court hearing nearly a decade after the controversial takeover.

For dfcu and the other defendants, the trial offers an opportunity to defend the transaction and challenge claims they maintain are without merit.

The case involves prominent international legal teams, with Greenberg Traurig representing the claimants and Freshfields representing dfcu, while other defendants have separate legal representation.

  👁 POST VIEWS: 130,561